Mike Alstott was a great player. A Buccaneers hero. As it is now, only one number is officially retired (I could be wrong - Gruber’s 74 could be). Lee Roy Selmon is Tampa Bay’s only Hall of Fame player and his #63 is retired as it should be.
But is Alstott a Hall of Fame player? Probably not. He played a position that rarely garners consideration. And if you retire 40, you’d also have to retire 99, 55, 20, 97 and 47. Of that list, I’d say that Sapp, Brooks and Lynch are sure Hall of Famers. Barber and Rice are probably on the bubble.
If you’re basing retiring 40 on Alstott’s likeability and place in the franchise then sure. Alstott was one of the most important players in franchise history. That will never change. Unless the organization is ready to retire numbers in mass, then the bar by which we measure a player’s merit should be re-examined.
Perhaps a number should be assigned to the hiring of Rich McKay and Tony Dungy. Their partnership and tenure is what turned this previously pathetic franchise around.
In either case, I will watch in pride as Alstott is honored. But I would say that the next number to be retired is 55. After that lets see what happens with the HoF.